Elliot Page’s ‘Second Nature’ Shatters the Gender Binary in Nature

Blog

“Second Nature” and the Queer Animal Kingdom: Why Elliot Page’s New Documentary Matters for Love, Gender & How We See Ourselves

Most of us grew up with the same story about nature: there are two sexes, two genders, and everything else is an anomaly. Straight pairings are “normal,” gay or trans people are “against nature,” and the animal world supposedly proves it.

But what happens when science tells a very different story—one where seahorse dads get pregnant, monkey troops are run by fierce matriarchs, and same-sex penguin couples lovingly raise chicks together? What happens when the natural world is not strictly binary, but gloriously diverse?

That’s the world explored in Second Nature, a new documentary directed by queer filmmaker Drew Denny and narrated by Oscar-nominated actor Elliot Page. The film dives into a growing body of research documenting gender and sexual diversity across the animal kingdom, and it’s already resonating deeply with queer and trans audiences who are tired of being told their existence is “unnatural.”

For a progressive dating app community—where people are actively unlearning old scripts about gender, relationships, and desire—this story hits close to home. Second Nature doesn’t just challenge myths about animals; it challenges the myths that have shaped our bodies, our relationships, and our sense of belonging.

Read the full article: “Second Nature”: Elliot Page on New Film Exploring Animal World Beyond the Binary (Democracy Now!)

What “Second Nature” Is About

A documentary that asks: What if nature has always been queer?

Second Nature brings together stunning footage of wildlife, interviews with evolutionary biologists, and personal reflections from its creators to show that diversity in sex, gender, and sexuality isn’t a human glitch—it’s a recurring theme in life on Earth.

Directed by Drew Denny, a queer filmmaker, the documentary is narrated by Elliot Page, who has been open about his journey as a trans and queer person. Page explains that he joined the project because he was “so moved by it and found it so affirming as a trans and queer person.” Denny shares that learning about animal life beyond binary concepts of sex and gender was nothing short of life-changing: “I finally felt in my body, for the first time, that I belong here on Earth, just like anybody else.”

The film features:

Pregnant male seahorses that flip traditional ideas of who carries and births offspring.
Matriarchal monkey troops where power, leadership, and social organization don’t mirror the patriarchal norms humans often assume are “natural.”
Same-sex pairings and non-heteronormative behaviors documented across species—from birds to mammals to insects.
Interviews with evolutionary biologists who explain how diversity in sex and gender expression can be adaptive, functional, and deeply embedded in ecosystems.

Second Nature is now showing in major cities across the United States, introducing mainstream audiences to a reality scientists have been documenting for years: nature is not straight, not strictly binary, and not here to validate human prejudice.

Why This Story Matters Right Now

Debunking the “against nature” argument

Anti-LGBTQ+ rhetoric has long leaned on a single, shaky claim: that queer and trans people are “unnatural.” When lawmakers argue against gender-affirming care, when pundits rail against “non-traditional” families, when relatives tell you your identity is a phase, “nature” is often used as a weapon.

But the science behind Second Nature shows that:

Same-sex behavior has been observed in hundreds of species.
Intersex traits and variations in sex characteristics are widespread in the animal kingdom.
Gendered roles (who nurtures, who leads, who fights, who mates with whom) vary wildly between species and even within species.

When Denny says she finally felt she belonged “here on Earth, just like anybody else,” she’s naming something many queer and trans people feel: the deep relief of realizing you’re not a mistake. You’re part of a broader pattern of life that has always included you.

Elliot Page as narrator: representation with depth

Elliot Page’s involvement is more than a casting choice; it’s a statement. As a trans man whose transition has played out under intense public scrutiny, Page brings lived experience to a film about belonging in a world that often tries to define you out of existence.

When a trans person narrates a documentary about the naturalness of gender diversity, it pushes back against the idea that transness is a modern invention or a social fad. It says: this isn’t new; it’s older than humanity. What’s new is the courage and visibility to name it.

Nature, Gender, and Desire: How This Connects to Dating and Relationships

Unlearning the “one right way” to be

On a progressive dating app, you’re likely to see pronoun options, multiple gender identities, and relationship structures that go beyond monogamous heterosexuality. But even in queer and progressive spaces, binary assumptions can linger: who should be “more masculine” or “more feminine,” who should initiate, who should earn more, who should want kids.

Second Nature offers a powerful counter-story: if animals can thrive in systems where males carry pregnancies, where females run the show, where same-sex pairs raise offspring, then our rigid expectations about who does what in relationships are cultural, not cosmic law.

For daters, this can be liberating:

Gender roles become optional, not mandatory. If seahorse dads can be the pregnant ones, your relationship doesn’t need to follow any pre-written script.
Queer love is not an exception. It’s part of a much larger pattern of diverse bonding and caretaking strategies across species.
Non-binary identities have natural analogues. Many animals don’t fit neatly into “male” or “female” roles or bodies, and yet their communities function, adapt, and survive.

Body affirmation through biology

For trans, intersex, and non-binary people, the body is often a battleground—socially, medically, politically. Learning that variation is baked into the natural world can shift how we relate to our own bodies.

It can mean:

Seeing your body not as “wrong,” but as one of many possible ways life expresses itself.
Feeling less pressure to justify your existence with perfect medical explanations or legal recognition.
Understanding that change—transition, hormone shifts, surgeries—is not a betrayal of nature but one more way humans shape and adapt their lives, just as other species do in their own ways.

For people dating across gender identities and experiences, this knowledge can also deepen empathy and curiosity. Instead of treating a partner’s gender journey as an exception that needs to be “explained,” we can see it as part of a much larger story of natural diversity.

Progressive Values in Focus: Science, Liberation, and Belonging

Science as a tool for liberation, not control

Historically, science has been used both to oppress and to liberate. The same disciplines that once tried to pathologize queer and trans people are now documenting the vast diversity that undermines rigid norms.

Second Nature sits squarely in a progressive tradition that uses science to:

Challenge oppressive myths (for example, that heterosexual, binary pairings are the only “natural” ones).
Validate lived experience by showing that what people feel in their bodies isn’t a personal failure, but part of a broader pattern.
Expand our moral imagination by showing that the way things are in one culture or era is not the way they must always be.

Progressive movements have always been at their strongest when they combine data with lived experience. In that sense, Second Nature is as much about politics as it is about biology: it tells a story that can shift how we argue, legislate, and care for each other.

Queer ecology and rethinking our place on Earth

There’s a growing field often called “queer ecology” that asks how queerness and environmentalism intersect. If nature itself is diverse, fluid, and resistant to simple categories, then protecting the environment also means protecting the full spectrum of ways life shows up—including queer and trans humans.

From a queer-ecology lens, Second Nature invites us to:

See ourselves as part of ecosystems, not separate from them.
Understand that attacking queer and trans people is, in a sense, attacking the diversity that makes ecosystems resilient.
Recognize that fighting for LGBTQ+ rights and fighting for climate and environmental justice are deeply connected struggles.

For progressive daters, this can expand what “compatibility” means. Values like sustainability, mutual care, and respect for the planet are increasingly part of how people choose partners. A film like Second Nature adds another layer: seeing queer love as aligned with the planet, not opposed to it.

Different Angles: How People Might Respond to “Second Nature”

For queer and trans viewers

For many queer and trans people, the film will likely feel affirming, even healing. Denny’s description of finally feeling like she belongs “here on Earth” echoes what many report when they first learn about queer animals: a sense of relief, joy, and connection.

But it’s also important to note: you don’t have to “prove” your identity is natural to deserve rights or respect. The film offers powerful evidence, but human dignity doesn’t depend on animal analogies.

For allies and people still learning

For straight, cis, or newly questioning viewers, Second Nature can be a gentle but profound education. It may:

Break down the idea that queer and trans identities are “modern confusion.”
Offer a non-defensive way to rethink assumptions (“If animals do this, maybe I need to adjust what I think of as normal”).
Encourage deeper listening to queer and trans people in their lives.

Photo by Stewart Munro on Unsplash